Selecting the Right Technology
Enter your keywords to find answers:
Compare wireless technologies for your application, including range, battery life, security, mesh networking and world-wide use.
No questions match your filter.
01Which technology should I use for an industrial sensor application?
Industrial sensor applications are quite fragmented, therefore it is difficult to recommend one specific technology. But a starting point is to consider the amount of data to be transferred, if battery operation is required, and what the typical range from a sensor to the data collector. Wireless M-Bus is a robust proven standard for low data-rate appliactions. For higher data rates, the general RC232 and Tinymesh modules can be considered. Read more about industrial applications here: https://radiocrafts.com/applications/wireless-sensor-networks/
02Which technology should I use for a meter reading application?
In Europe the Wireless M-Bus is the preferred standard for meter reading applications. Also outside Europe the Wireless M-Bus is getting more popular, and Radiocrafts offer module variants adapted to different markets. The ZigBee protocol has been used in the US and UK. The Tinymesh protocol is also a good choice for electricity meters connected in a mesh. Read more about automatic meter reading here: https://radiocrafts.com/applications/automatic-meter-reading/
03Which technology gives the best range and coverage?
The range cannot be considered independently from other requirements, because it relates to data throughput, local radio regulations etc. But in general the following factors ensure the best range:
-low RF frequency (provided the size of the antenna is sufficient)
-low data rate
-low RF channel bandwidth
-sensitivity of the receiver (which depend on the data rate and channel bandwidth)
-high RF transmission power
-antenna gain
Our 169MHz products will have the longest range. They reach several kilometers in practical appliactions. The mesh network technologies (Zigbee and Tinymesh) can also extend the coverage by using multiple hops to reach a node. Repeaters (Wireless M-Bus and KNX) and multi-hop (RC232) will also extend the range. The Sigfox technology is based on a cellular network to give city/country wide coverage. Check application note AN021 for further details here.
04Which technology do you recommend for battery powered applications?
In battery operated applications the device should be in sleep mode as much as possible. The Wireless M-Bus protocol was designed for battery operated meters, and will provide 15-20 years of battery lifetime. Also the RC232 modules can be configured to sleep mode with less than 1 uA current consumption, only woken up to do transmissions when needed. The Sigfox modules are also very low power and suitable for battery operated LPWAN applications. Mesh networks use router nodes to retransmit messages, and therefore need mains power.
05Which technologies provide security (privacy and integrity of data)?
Several technologies offered by Radiocrafts provide encryption of data using AES-128, including Wireless M-Bus, ZigBee, RC232, Tinymesh and Sigfox. AES-128 is a well-established symmetric key encryption technology (same key used for encryption and decryption) that provides privacy and integrity of data. It use a 16 byte secret key that is stored in the radio module.
06Which technologies can be used world-wide?
There is no real global radio regulation, but the 2.45 GHz band can be used world-wide, with some differences in maximum transmission power. By combining frequencies, it is also possible to make systems with variants than will meet most local radio regulations around the world using the 400 and 800/900 MHz bands. Radiocrafts offer solutions compliant with regulations in Europe, USA/Canada, Brazil, Russia, India, Korea, Japan, China, Australia/New Zealand and South Africa, and more.
07When should I use a mesh network?
Mesh networks are best when small amount of control/monitoring data shall be sent to/from nodes in a mains operated network such as electricity meters or lights in a home automation system. Mesh networks use router nodes to retransmit messages, and therefore need mains power. It may be combined with battery operated “end nodes”, but this will not take part in the network routing.
08What is the typical communication range of a radio module?
The range will depend on the environment as well as the technology (data rate, frequency, output power etc). An indication of line-of-sight range for comparison, is given in the Product Number Overview. https://radiocrafts.com/uploads/radiocrafts_product_number_overview_20151027.pdf
The AN021 shows a few good examples of real life tests of range as well as show how to calculate range.
09What is the difference between RC232 and Tinymesh?
The RC232 and Tinymesh protocols share the same PHY (frequency and modulation) and to some extent the MAC layer (frame format). But the RC232 is a point-to-point/multipoint protocol (with a multihop feature), while Tinymesh is a mesh protocol (all nodes in the network is a repeater for other nodes).
10What is the difference between narrowband and wideband?
The terms “narrowband” and “wideband” refer to the actual radio channel bandwidth. A common definition (ETSI) of narrowband is when 25 kHz or less is used for the radio channel. The benefit of using a narrow channel is the lower noise bandwidth and hence better sensitivity and range. The advantage of wideband is the capability to transfer higher data rates. Because of the high radio performance associated with narrowband, the term is being misused as seen from an industrial radio point of view. Unfortunately LTE NB-IoT use the “narrowband” term even for a 180 kHz bandwidth, which in terms of industrial radio is understood as wideband. Even LoRa is not a narrowband technology as it is based on a frequency chip spanning over more than 100 kHz. When discussing LPWAN it is only Sigfox that use true narrowband technology.
11What is a Mesh network?
It is a network laid out in a mesh topology where the nodes also re-transmit data from other nodes, whereby the need for a direct access point is removed or reduced to a single gateway. The advantage of a mesh network is that it is scalable (it is very easy to add a new node) and robust (the network will continue to operate even if one node goes down). The drawback is that the individual nodes needs to be complex to handle data from many other nodes, has a relatively high latency that can change if nodes are added or removed, and due to the complexity will use more power. Radiocrafts provide Tinymesh and ZigBee/6LoWPAN modules.
12What applications use ZigBee?
ZigBee was developed for home and building automation, but is also used for some industrial sensor networks and meter reading applications. It is best for control/monitoring application with low amounts of data. As Zigbee use a mesh network, all nodes may take part in the forwarding of messages, and must therefore be main operated. Because the frequency is 2.45 GHz, the range is limited and there are losses in building materials, but this is compensated by the multi-hop feature of the mesh protocol provided there are enough nodes in the network.
13How is it possible to get the data into the cloud?
Radiocrafts provides IoT solutions that are easy to connect to the cloud. The Sigfox technology is inherently connected to the cloud through its network of base stations. For the other technologies a gateway is used to send data to/from the local radio network to the internet (cloud). Radiocrafts work with gateway providers that enable backend ethernet and cellular connections for all our wireless protocols.